Dining

 

The island offers many fine and interesting restaurants to suit even the most finicky palate. You can dress up and dine in a 5 star restaurant or go straight from the beach and eat in your bathing suit and flip-flops. The island is known for it's fresh seafood which is caught locally and served at many restaurants or can be bought at our local fish market. Local delicacies include stone crab claws (October - May), shrimp, grouper, Mahi and tuna. Listed below are a few of our favorite spots on the island:

The Sandbar
100 Spring Ave. Anna Maria (north end of the island)
(941) 778-0444
This restaurant sits right on the beach and offers dining inside in the dining room or outside on their deck. Menus differ inside and out, they feature seafood, salads, steaks, etc. Be sure to catch the sunset from the outside deck - they have one of the best views on the island!

The Sign of the Mermaid
9707 Gulf Drive (north end of the island)
(941) 778-9399
This little house turned restaurant is very cozy and charming. They do not have a liquor license, but they invite you to BYOB and will gladly serve your beverage of choice to you. The menu features fresh seafood as well as steaks, chicken and duck. We are particularly fond of their salads & appetizers. 

The Beach Bistro
6600 Gulf Drive Holmes Beach
(941) 778-6444
If you're looking for a nice evening out, or if celebrating a special occasion, this is the place to go. This restaurant has received many awards for it's cuisine and service.  They offer a fine wine list and entrees with a gourmet twist. Reservations are suggested.

Duffy's Tavern
5808 Marina Dr. Holmes Beach, FL 34217
(941) 778-2501
We suggest you visit Duffy's at least once during your visit on the island. You will find locals and visitors bellied up at the bar, as Peggy serves up some of the coldest beer and tastiest burgers we've had. It is a small place with only a few tables, but it's big on charm. If you can't get a seat right away, hang out, it's worth the wait! 

Paradise Bagel
3210 East bay Drive (in the Walgreens shopping center) Holmes Beach
(941) 779-1212
Our family frequents this friendly little place often. They serve breakfast and lunch and offer a variety of bagel sandwiches, soups, salads, etc. Our favorites are Jackie's chicken salad and the "eggel" (bacon, egg & cheese on a bagel).

The BeachHouse
200 Gulf Drive N. Bradenton Beach
(941) 779-2222
We recommend the BeachHouse for lunch, after a day on the beach! They offer inside dining and outside dining on their deck. They sit right on the beach and have volleyball nets just south of the restaurant. They offer some chaise lounges on the beach in front of the restaurant as well as outside showers and bathrooms. Their menu features fresh fish, sandwiches, salads, etc. 

The Mar Vista
760 Broadway Longboat Key
(941) 383-2391
Just over the bridge on Longboat Key, the Mar Vista sits on the bay. You can access the restaurant by car or boat, and docking is available if you decide to visit by boat. The interior of the restaurant offers "old Florida charm", make sure you sign a dollar bill and staple it to the walls or ceiling! You can also dine on their outside deck. We are fond of their "steamer pots", a pot filled with steamed mussels, clams, potatoes, etc. They also offer entrees, fish, burgers, salads, etc.

Star Fish Company
12306 46th Ave. W.
(just over the Cortez Bridge in Cortez village, back on the water)
(941) 794-1243
Our favorite place to buy seafood! They offer a great selection of fresh fish, shrimp and stone crabs (when in season). They catch most everything themselves and it's always FRESH! They also have a small restaurant, which serves sandwiches.